Thousand Trails Isn’t Overselling. It’s Underselling, and That’s Worse for You

Almost every Thousand Trails member I meet thinks the company sells too many memberships. ELS’s own filings say it sold fewer this summer than last, in the one quarter of the year built for selling. Fewer camping passes, fewer upgrades, fewer free passes. That is not the problem you think it is. It is a worse one.

Table of Contents

Members think Thousand Trails is overselling. The filings say it is underselling, and that is worse news for you than a crowded park.

The Campfire Theory

If you’ve spent any time around a Thousand Trails campfire, you’ve heard it. Somebody has been trying to book a summer weekend at one of the Oregon coast parks for three weeks straight, the reservation calendar is a solid wall of “unavailable,” and the guy two sites over leans back in his camp chair and says what half the circle is already thinking: they’re selling too many memberships, they’re cramming us in, they’ve oversold the whole system. I’ve heard some version of that at nearly every park I’ve stayed at this year. I’ve stayed at a lot of them.

I get it.

Campers around a campfire at an Oregon RV park, one holding up his phone in frustration
Every campfire has one. Usually it's me.

It feels true when you’re staring at that calendar. But I spend an unreasonable amount of my free time reading Equity LifeStyle’s SEC filings (my hobby, don’t judge), and the numbers point the other way. Thousand Trails isn’t selling too many memberships. It’s selling fewer of them every year. This past summer, the one stretch of the calendar when selling a camping membership should be about as hard as selling cold beer at a ballgame, it sold fewer than it did the summer before.

And over the long haul, I think that’s worse news for members than overselling would ever be.

Here’s where this is going. First, the summer numbers. Then the four-year trend, for both the camping pass and the new two- and four-year memberships. Then why the parks still feel full anyway, including a new reason that has nothing to do with headcount; whether ELS is carving up the parks and handing our sites to paying guests; what the CEO said about it; and finally why a shrinking membership should worry you more than a crowded one. Skim the boxes if you’re in a hurry. The rest is the proof.

Quick background for anyone who hasn’t read my other pieces. Thousand Trails is owned by Equity LifeStyle Properties (ELS), a publicly traded company that owns hundreds of RV resorts, manufactured-home communities and marinas. Because ELS is public, it has to report its numbers to the SEC every quarter, and Thousand Trails is in there: how many members, how many camping passes sold, how many upgrades, what it spent on marketing. Most members have never looked at any of it. You don’t need to.

That’s my job.

The Quarter Built for Selling

The short version: with full parks, its biggest ad campaign ever and the camping pass on sale for $475, Thousand Trails sold fewer camping passes, fewer new memberships and fewer free trial passes this summer than last. It literally can’t even give these things away.

ELS splits its year into quarters, and the third quarter (July, August, September) is the one that matters for Thousand Trails. It holds most of the Memorial Day to Labor Day stretch, which is the busiest camping season of the year and the time when the parks are fullest. ELS runs a summer-long social media campaign over that same stretch called “100 Days of Camping,” and on its October earnings call the CEO said this year’s version drew more than 100 million views, double last year’s.

August is also, traditionally, when Thousand Trails runs its best sale of the year. And on September 21, still inside the quarter, the Thousand Trails website was advertising a “Fall Flash Sale” on the entry-level camping pass: $300 off the $775 list price, down to $475. That’s the deepest discount I’ve found anywhere in the archived price history of that page.

A packed summer campground behind an empty membership sales booth with a sale sign and a basket of free passes
Full park. Empty booth. A basket of free passes nobody is taking.

So think about what that quarter had going for it. Full parks, happy campers, a giant ad campaign, the big August sale, and a price tag of $475. If Thousand Trails is going to sell memberships, it sells them then.

There’s one more reason this particular summer matters. In early 2025, Thousand Trails stopped selling the old lifetime upgrades (big money up front, keep it as long as you like) and switched to the two- and four-year memberships most of you know by their tier names, Journey, Explore, Adventure and so on, with a much smaller up-front cost and higher annual dues. (ELS’s filings never use the tier names; they just call them “two- to four-year term subscription products.” The tier names are mine.) That made summer 2025 the first summer on the new product, and it makes summer 2026 the first time we can compare one summer on the new product to another. Apples to apples, finally.

Here’s what the third quarter looked like, this year against last:

July–September20262025Change
Camping passes sold (paid)4,5515,005−9.1%
Free one-year passes through RV dealers6,0416,422−5.9%
Two- and four-year memberships sold ("upgrades")1,6971,745−2.8%
Spent on membership sales and marketing$4.8 million$4.2 million+14.7%
Total members at September 30107,387—down 470 since June 30

Source: ELS quarterly supplemental financial information, Q3 2026 and Q3 2025. ELS reports these as Paid Membership Origination, Promotional Membership Origination, Membership Upgrade Volume, Membership sales and marketing, and Total Memberships. ELS reports year-to-date totals; the quarterly figures are my arithmetic from them.

ELS spent about 15% more on selling memberships, ran a social campaign it says doubled last year’s views, put the camping pass on the deepest sale I can find on record, and sold 454 fewer camping passes than it did the summer before. Read that again.

Fewer camping passes. Fewer two- and four-year memberships. Fewer free one-year passes handed out at the RV dealers. Fewer everything. The free pass costs the customer nothing. It literally can’t even give these things away.

Upgrades came closest, down less than 3%. Close, though, isn’t up. And every quarter of 2026 so far has sold fewer upgrades than the same quarter of 2025.

This Isn't One Bad Summer

The short version: paid camping pass sales are down about 26% since 2022, the new memberships are selling 9% behind last year, total members are down about 16%, and there are about 18% fewer members for every site you can actually book.

If this were one soft quarter, I wouldn’t bother writing about it. It isn’t. Here are the two things Thousand Trails sells for money, by year, straight from ELS’s reports. The camping pass is the front door. The upgrade is the step up, and until 2025 it was the lifetime product.

Five panels, 2022 through 2026 so far, the line at a campground membership sales booth getting shorter each year
Same booth, same salesman, five summers. The line keeps getting shorter, and 2026 is already behind before it's over.
YearCamping passes sold (paid)Upgrades sold
202223,2374,068
202320,7583,858
202419,5394,086
202517,1505,945 (first year of the new memberships)
2026, through September13,319 (vs. 14,325 a year earlier)4,284 (vs. 4,704 a year earlier)

Source: ELS Forms 10-K FY2022–FY2025 and supplemental financial information through Q3 2026 (TTC Sales / Paid Membership Origination; Membership Upgrade Volume).

Chart 57 — The front door and the step-up: both sold fewer in 2026 than in 2025. Source: ELS Forms 10-K FY2022–FY2025 and quarterly supplemental financial information through Q3 2026; 2026 is year-to-date.

Two different stories in that table, and both of them end the same way. The camping pass has gone straight down: about 26% fewer sold in 2025 than in 2022, and 2026 is running 7% behind 2025. The upgrades did something else. Sales were flat around 4,000 a year on the lifetime product, then jumped 45% in 2025 when the cheaper two- and four-year memberships arrived. That’s the new product doing what it was supposed to do, and credit where it’s due. But the jump lasted one year. Through September 2026, upgrades are 9% behind the same stretch of 2025, and every single quarter this year has come in under the same quarter last year.

So the front door is narrowing and the step-up has stopped climbing. Fewer new people coming in, and fewer of the people already in stepping up.

The total member count tells the same story. It peaked at 128,439 at the end of 2022 and stood at 107,387 at the end of September, down about 16%. (That count includes the free one-year dealer passes, roughly 20,700 of them at the end of 2025, so the number of people actually paying dues is smaller still.) I walked through the full history, back to when ELS bought the membership business in 2008, in Is Thousand Trails Membership as Healthy as ELS’s Member Count Suggests?, which is the place to go if you want the whole Thousand Trails membership decline laid out year by year.

Chart 41 — Thousand Trails members, 2008–2025. Source: ELS Forms 10-K FY2008–FY2025 (Item 2 / MD&A Overview). Free trials are separated from the count only from 2018.

Now put that against the campsites. Of the roughly 26,000 sites at the 82 membership campgrounds, about 6,200 are rented out by the year and aren’t available to you. Divide the members by the sites that are left and you get about 6.6 members per site at the end of 2022, 6.1 in 2023, 5.7 in 2024 and 5.4 in 2025, and it has held at about 5.4 this year. (My arithmetic, using ELS’s own counts. Free-trial members are in there, and obviously nobody camps all at once.) That’s around 18% fewer members per available site in under four years, and the number has gone down every single year.

Fewer people. Same dirt.

For a sense of scale, there’s a ceiling here, too. For ten years, ELS’s own annual report told investors that in certain states, “as a result of government regulations and provisions in certain of the right-to-use or campground membership agreements,” it was prohibited from selling more than ten memberships per site. That sentence quietly dropped out of the annual report in 2018; whether the limit still applies today, the filings no longer say. At about 5.4 members per available site, Thousand Trails is selling roughly half of what that old limit allowed. Count every site, annuals included, and it’s closer to four.

Chart 50 — Reported count vs. paying members, 2018–2025. Source: ELS Forms 10-K FY2018–FY2025; from 2024 the paying remainder is disclosed as "the majority of," so 2024 and 2025 are ceilings.

To be fair to the new memberships, they are doing better than the old lifetime product did. Upgrades sold this past summer were up 48% from the summer of 2024, the last summer on the lifetime product. The lower up-front price brought more people through that door. It’s just bringing fewer through it now than it did in its first year, and the front door, the camping pass, keeps getting narrower.

So Why Can't I Get a Site?

The short version: the members who quit are the light users, the ones who stay are the heavy users, and a lot more of the members who are left now have the long booking window. Fewer members, way more nights each, and more of them booking six months out.

This is the part where I owe you some honesty, because the guy at the campfire isn’t crazy. The parks do feel full, especially in summer and especially on the coast. Both of these things are true at once: the membership is shrinking, and the reservation calendar is still tight.

There are two reasons, as best I can tell, and the second one is new.

The first is who leaves. The members who quit are mostly the ones who weren’t using it much. Somebody who camps two weekends a year eventually does the math on the dues and lets it go. The full-timer who lives in the system, the snowbird doing a circuit between three nearby parks, the retired couple who books the max stay and then waits out their week just outside the gate and comes right back? They stay. They’re getting the most for their money, so of course they stay. I covered why that happens in my piece on Thousand Trails frozen dues, and I see it every week in the parks.

So you end up with fewer members, but the ones who remain use a lot more nights each.

Fewer members. Heavier users.

The second reason is the booking window, and this one is a direct result of the new memberships. Under the old system, the long reservation window came with a big check. If you wanted to book 180 days out instead of 60, you were writing something like $16,000 up front for a lifetime Adventure-level membership. Most people didn’t. So most of the pie was camping-pass holders booking 60 days out, and a small slice at the top had the long window.

At a campground reservation counter, a camper with a 60-day calendar loses the lakeside site to a camper holding a 180-day calendar stamped full
Sixty days out versus 180 days out. The lakeside site goes to the long calendar every time.

Now the same long window comes with a two- or four-year membership and a few hundred dollars down. ELS’s filings put the full price at $4,000 to $8,000 over two years, paid mostly as dues, but the barrier at the register is nothing like $16,000. And people took the deal: 5,945 of these sold in 2025 against 4,086 lifetime upgrades in 2024, up 45%, and that doesn’t count the ones sold this year. Every one of those is a member who used to compete with you at 60 days and now competes with you at 180.

So even as the total pie shrinks, a bigger slice of it holds the long window. The prime summer weekends on the coast get taken six months out, by more people than ever had the right to take them. The calendar you’re staring at in March for July isn’t full because there are more members. It’s full because more of the members who are left can book that far ahead.

Add the fact that these same parks also rent sites by the year, by the season and by the night, and a shrinking membership can still produce a full July.

That’s what’s filling the calendar, not a sales team selling too much. If anything, the sales team is selling too little.

Are They Carving Up Our Parks?

The short version: they may in fact be reserving more sites for paying guests. But if they are, they’re making less money per site. Rent from seasonal and nightly stays at Thousand Trails parks is down 18% in three years.

Here’s the other complaint, and it’s a sharper one than “too many members.” Picture a Thousand Trails park with 100 sites. Forty years ago, all 100 were for members. That’s what the membership bought. Somewhere along the way, 20 of them became annual sites, rented out by the year to one RV that never leaves. Another 20 got set aside for retail guests, the folks who pull in off the highway and pay by the night or the week. That left 60 for the rest of us. And the fear is that the pie keeps getting cut thinner: 20 annuals, 30 retail, 50 for members. Then 40. Then 30.

Before-and-now maps of the same campground, with the green member section shrinking and the orange retail section growing
The fear, drawn out: the member slice of the park shrinks, the paying-guest slice grows. The numbers are made up. The worry isn't.

That’s a real argument, and I want to take it seriously, because the filings can answer part of it and can’t answer the rest.

What they can answer: the annual slice. ELS reports how many sites at the membership campgrounds are rented by the year, and the number hasn’t grown. There were 6,390 of them at the end of 2022 and 6,014 at the end of 2025. It’s climbing again this year, to 6,226 in September, but that’s still fewer than four years ago. (For the record, ELS’s own definition says those sites are rented “by members.” Doesn’t help you a bit. A member parked on a site all year is a site you can’t book, so as far as you’re concerned it’s out of the program. But it’s not growing.)

What they can’t answer: the retail slice. ELS does not disclose how many sites it sets aside for nightly and weekly guests, at any park, in any year. Nobody outside the company knows whether that slice went from 20 to 30. What ELS does disclose is what those guests paid:

Chart 56 — Rent from seasonal and nightly stays at Thousand Trails parks, 2022–2025. Source: ELS supplemental financial information, Membership Campgrounds table, Seasonal/Transient RV base rental income.
YearRent from seasonal and nightly staysRent from annual sitesAnnual sites
2022$24.3 million$25.9 million6,390
2023$21.0 million$27.8 million6,154
2024$21.3 million$29.3 million5,902
2025$20.0 million$30.5 million6,014
September 30, 2026——6,226

Source: ELS supplemental financial information, Membership Campgrounds table (Seasonal/Transient RV base rental income, Annual RV base rental income, Annual Site Count).

Rent from seasonal and nightly guests at Thousand Trails parks fell from $24.3 million in 2022 to $20.0 million in 2025. Down 18%. Annual rent went the other way, up 18%, but on fewer sites, so that’s price, not more sites: about $4,100 per annual site in 2022 and about $5,100 in 2025, by my arithmetic. Put the two together and everything ELS collects at these parks that isn’t dues was $50.3 million in 2022 and $50.5 million in 2025. Flat. Four years.

Now the part that matters for the 100-site argument. ELS lumps seasonal and nightly rent into one line, so I can’t tell you how much of that $20 million is weeklong seasonal folks and how much is Friday-night drive-ups. (My guess, and it’s only a guess: mostly nightly, because ELS says it counts a season-long site at a northern park as an annual site, so most of the seasonal crowd at the Washington and Pennsylvania parks is already in the annual column.) ELS’s own explanation for the drop across its whole RV business is more competing campgrounds opening back up, softer demand in some markets and fewer Canadians.

But here’s what doesn’t depend on any of that. The money is down 18%. If ELS set aside the same number of retail sites in 2025 as in 2022, it made 18% less on each one. If it set aside more, like the campfire says, it made even less per site than that. The only way the per-site number went up is if ELS cut the retail slice, which is the opposite of the complaint.

So, are they reserving more of our sites for paying guests? Maybe. The filings can’t tell us. But if they are, they’re making less money per site doing it. That’s a strange way to run a land grab.

What Management Said About It

The short version: the CEO’s answer to falling membership was price. She called it “a deliberate trade-off.” Her words, not mine.

On the October 21 earnings call, exactly one Wall Street analyst asked about Thousand Trails. John Kim of BMO put it simply: membership volume keeps going down while revenue keeps going up, so how much further can ELS push the price to make up for fewer members? Nobody on the call disputed the premise that volume is falling. Not one person.

CEO Marguerite Nader’s answer was mostly about price. ELS has “pushed the rate a little bit,” she said, and the upgrade program “came with an increased dues base” and is “the driver of that dues-based increase.” On upgrades, she said, “I think we will continue to see an increase in that activity.”

Lay that last line next to the table above. Every quarter of 2026 has sold fewer upgrades than the same quarter of 2025. I’ll let you be the jury on that one.

Back in July, she was even more direct about the strategy, calling it “a deliberate trade-off with an emphasis on the higher rate rather than the volume.” I’ll give her credit for that, because it’s honest. That is the strategy, stated plainly by the person running it.

Price over people.

Before anybody grabs a pitchfork, that isn’t automatically bad news for members. More revenue is more revenue, and revenue at a park is what gives a company a reason to fix the bathhouse and regrade the roads. The real question is the one the analyst asked: how long can price keep doing all the work while the number of people paying it keeps shrinking?

Why Underselling Is Worse for You

The short version: the parks cost the same to run whether five members or seven are paying for each site. Fewer members means less reason to spend money on the parks. That’s the risk.

Overselling would at least mean the business was growing. A growing business is one a company wants to put money into. So here’s the honest version of the worry, and it isn’t the one you hear at the campfire.

Fewer members per site sounds great if you’re the one trying to book, and today it mostly is. But Thousand Trails is a fixed-cost business. The pool still needs chemicals, the roads still need grading and the bathhouse still needs cleaning whether five members per site are paying for it or seven. Those costs don’t shrink when the member count does. What pays for them is revenue, and what keeps a company putting money into a park is the revenue that park produces.

Two panels: a crowd of campers filling a pool fund jar beside a sparkling pool, then a few campers and an empty jar beside a green, neglected pool
Same pool, same bathhouse, same costs. Fewer people paying for them.

Right now that revenue is still growing. Annual membership subscriptions, the line where everyone’s dues land, your camping pass, a lifetime member’s dues, and everything paid for the new two- and four-year memberships, grew 9.2% in the third quarter. By management’s own account, the driver is those new memberships, which carry higher dues. That’s members choosing to pay more to get more. Nobody’s being squeezed beyond the cost-of-living increase that’s been in the contract all along.

But that increase has gotten smaller every quarter this year: about $1.96 million over the prior year in the first quarter, $1.92 million in the second, $1.64 million in the third. And here’s the catch. A lifetime member can’t buy one of the new memberships; whatever they own is what they own. So the only people who can buy them are camping-pass holders, and that’s the pool that’s shrinking. Fewer camping passes sold today means fewer buyers for the higher-dues memberships tomorrow.

Follow that chain to the end. Fewer members. Slower revenue growth. Less reason to put money into the parks. A worse experience for the members who are left. That’s the risk, and it’s why I’d rather see Thousand Trails selling more memberships, not fewer.

To be clear, we’re not there. I went looking for evidence that ELS is letting the parks rot, through ten years of its property-level filings. I didn’t find it. The money is going into the parks, just not evenly. That’s my next piece, coming in December.

What I'd Tell a Member

If you’re mad about booking, aim it at the right target. The data doesn’t show a company selling too many memberships. It shows a company selling fewer, to a smaller group of members who use the system harder, book further out, and pay more.

If you’re a light user wondering whether to renew, the trend is working slightly in your favor on availability (fewer members per site), and against you on price (the plan, in management’s own words, is rate over volume). And if you’re a camping-pass holder losing the summer weekends at 60 days, understand that the people beating you to them aren’t new members. They’re members who stepped up.

And if you hold one of the old lifetime contracts, especially one with frozen dues, understand that you’re holding something ELS stopped selling, can’t easily take back, and has to keep honoring as the rest of the membership shrinks around you. That’s worth knowing before you make any decision about it.

The campfire theory was that Thousand Trails is greedy for more members. The filings say it’s settling for fewer. Long term, I’d rather the company be fighting to grow the thing I’m paying into.

Wouldn’t you?

About me, and my interests. I’m a lawyer and former CEO, and I write about Thousand Trails and Equity LifeStyle Properties here at LiveFreeRV.com. I run a resale board where Thousand Trails members buy and sell memberships, I consult with buyers and sellers of these contracts for a fee, and I’m eligible for Thousand Trails’ standard referral fee when I send a prospective buyer to its sales staff. That work is where my knowledge of these contracts comes from. To my knowledge I hold no position in ELS stock. The figures in this piece come from ELS’s annual reports and quarterly supplemental packages, the transcripts of its July and October 2026 earnings calls, and the Thousand Trails website as archived by the Internet Archive. Where I did the math, I say so. Where it’s my opinion, I say that too.

Ty's TakeAways.

Ty Chapman

Thousand Trails isn’t overselling. Paid camping pass sales fell about 26% from 2022 to 2025, total members are down about 16% from the 2022 peak, and members per available site have fallen every year, from about 6.6 to about 5.4.

Summer 2026 was the first apples-to-apples summer on the new two- and four-year memberships. With more marketing, a big campaign and a $475 flash sale, ELS sold fewer camping passes, fewer new memberships and fewer free dealer passes than summer 2025. Fewer everything.

The new memberships beat the lifetime product in 2025, then fell 9% behind through September 2026. The front door is narrowing and the step-up has stopped climbing.

The parks still feel full for two reasons: the members who stay are the heavy users, and the cheap step-up put the long booking window in a lot more hands. Fewer members, more nights each, more of them booking six months out.

Annual sites haven’t grown since 2022. ELS may be reserving more sites for nightly and weekly guests, but if it is, it’s making less per site: that rent is down 18% in three years.

Revenue is still growing, mostly from members buying the higher-dues memberships, but that growth is slowing every quarter, and lifetime members can’t buy them at all. In a fixed-cost business, a shrinking membership is a long-term risk to park investment. I looked for evidence ELS is neglecting the parks and didn’t find it; more on that in December.

Thinking About Getting One?

First things first — if you want to know what a membership actually costs in 2026, I’ve put together Complete Pricing and Membership Guide Here. It covers every tier, what you get, and how to figure out which one makes sense for your situation.

One thing worth knowing: the price on the Thousand Trails website is rarely the best price available. Through my referral link, members regularly save hundreds of dollars off the published rate. I’d love to connect you with the same specialist I used — no pressure, no pitch, just a real conversation. Click on the Image Below to get started with a free no-obligation consultation and access exclusive pricing!

For sale right now · Ty Runs the Sale

Memberships Ty is selling right now

Contract read by Ty · funds held until Thousand Trails confirms the transfer. See everything on the Exchange →

Explore Your Options.

Used if you’ll hold it long and you know how you camp. New if you’re short-term, need payments, or need to be camping next month. Not sure which you are? That’s the call.
MOST POPULAR
REAL LISTINGS · FREE TO USE
Browse the Exchange
The free board I run for used memberships — real memberships from real owners, every listing screened before it goes live, no broker in the middle. Nothing that fits yet? Set a free alert and you’ll hear the moment one lists.
INDEPENDENT EXPERT
CALL + WRITTEN REVIEW · $89
Talk to Ty
Fifty minutes on the phone with a lawyer who reads Thousand Trails contracts for fun and lives full-time in the system. If you have a specific contract, I provide a written review as well. I work with both new and used, so you get the real trade-offs of each — what I want is for you to end up in the right one for how you travel.
FASTEST TO CAMPING
WORKS FOR THOUSAND TRAILS · FREE
Talk to a TT Specialist
Membership specialists work for Thousand Trails, and their job is to sell you a new membership — but the one I send people to is honest, low-pressure, and can usually beat the website price. If new is the right fit for how you travel, this is the fastest and cheapest way to get one.

Chasing great mountain biking, camping smart, and living full-time in an RV. Hard-won wisdom. Zero fluff. Live Free. Adventure Often

Quick Links.

Live Free RV × Thousand Trails
New, Used, or Selling?

Every Thousand Trails option in one place — a specialist for new, the Exchange for used, and me for straight answers.

Sell a Membership — Free → Browse Used Memberships → 🔔 Set a free buyer alert Not Sure? Start Here → Book a Call with Ty — → Buying new? Talk to a TT specialist
Live Free. Adventure Often. 🚐✨

More From My ELS Research

I read Equity LifeStyle’s SEC filings so you don’t have to. The articles below are the rest of that series, some written for members and some for the Wall Street crowd, and all of it lives on my ELS Analysis page along with every chart I’ve built.

Ty Chapman relaxing for lunch during a hike at Big Bend National Park.

A Little Bit About Me.

I started writing this blog as a way to capture the adventurous and free lifestyle I’m privileged to live. I’ve traveled to over 28 countries and 35 U.S States. I’ve lived aboard in multiple countries and averaged over 100 days a year of travel for work. I’ve skied and hiked all over the world – and my new obsession is mountain biking.

What I bring to you isn’t AI generated. It’s based on my feet on the ground – or sometimes conversations with locals. Click here to read more about me! And, for a State-By-State guide of Where I’ve been and Where I’m headed, make sure to check out my Itinerary and Destination Page by clicking here!!!

 

 

🏕 Join the Live Free RV Crew
Free swag. Invites. First to know. No spam — ever.